Hail To The Idea Thief

November 30, 2010

“Give credit where credit is due.”

Surely, you’ve heard that phrase uttered at some point in your life. The message is simple: if an idea wasn’t yours, don’t try to pass it off as yours. If you’ve ever written a research paper, you’ve put this practice to use. In a research paper, you can’t just copy and paste something that someone else said and put it in yours and expect the professor to give you an A+. No, that practice is called plagiarism. And yes, it’s bad.

But when is it okay to stop giving credit? When can you say that, although you may not have originated the idea, the idea is something that you believe in? The idea, the philosophy, is yours, so when can you stop name-dropping and telling who converted your way of thinking?

If you believe in the gift economy, do you have to credit Seth Godin every time that you mention it? If you believe that the ROI on social media cannot be easily quantified, do you have to mention David Meerman Scott when you argue your case with someone? If you’ve embraced the Long Tail, do you have to reference Chris Anderson?

Some ideas are meant to spread. And in order for them to spread, they must become your ideas. They must become something that you believe in so passionately that they become a part of you. And you become a part of them.

I willingly admit that I am not a very original person. When I’m asked to solve problems, I can’t always come up with an original solution. But I have no problem taking someone else’s solution and applying it to my problem and situation. In some ways, I may be an idea thief. If I see that something works, I have no problem in implementing it into my daily life.

If I see that someone has come up with an organization system that is better than mine, his system becomes my system. When I see someone who is a better communicator than I am, I try to identify his mojo and then — you guessed it — I try to steal it.

This is why I enjoy talking to people who work in industries completely different from mine. You never know what you can learn from these people. You never know what ideas you can steal from them and implement into your business. The possibilities are endless.

Sometimes I wonder if we may put too much emphasis on originality and creativity. Sure, these elements are important, but it’s difficult for all of us to be original and creative every single day in every single situation. If you are unable to come up with an original idea, steal one. Of course, you have to make the call on whether you should give credit or not.

Quite frankly, if I ask you to solve a problem that I have, I don’t care if the solution is your own. All I care about is whether it works.

Hail to the idea thief!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • http://www.conorneill.com Conor

    In the fine words of my countryman Oscar Wilde “Talent borrows. Genius steals.” Keep stealing… although you end by proving that if I believe something then it is my idea because it resonates with me… I guess the true measure is whether your life is lived in accordance with the words you speak.

  • http://jakelacaze.com/ Jake LaCaze

    Isn’t that the point of social media? The point of blogging, tweeting, and connecting on Facebook? — to share ideas and to “steal” ideas from others? Honestly, that’s been my intention from the beginning and I see no reason that should change. Hell, I’ve “stolen” from you on a few occasions. ;)

  • Pingback: Conor Neill

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Hail To The Thief -- Topsy.com

  • Pingback: Jake LaCaze

  • Pingback: Jake LaCaze

  • http://melissacooley.com/ Melissa

    Well, in the David Meerman Scott example you gave, it may lend credence to your argument if you were to mention his name (given his status as a thought leader).

    But I do understand your point. Does Tom Peters have to be mentioned in the same breath as “Personal Branding” is? No, of course not. The idea has been so thoroughly discussed over the years that it is a part of a general body of knowledge. Really, that would seem to be the purpose behind ideas like this. If no one were to put those innovative perspectives into practice, the person who originally came up with the idea wouldn’t become known for his/her influence on what we think and how we act. That influence is the true power of those ideas.

    But if you happened to be part of an inner circle with Tom Peters, learned of a revolutionary idea that he was planning to introduce in his next book, and then rushed out to put forth your own knock-off of the idea and claim it as your own? That’s a horse of a different color — completely unethical, in my opinion.

  • Pingback: I Hate Social Media

  • http://jakelacaze.com/ Jake LaCaze

    In your last example, as you said, “a horse of a different color”, and I agree with you completely. By the way, great to have you back in the blogosphere and Twittersphere, Melissa.

  • http://melissacooley.com/ Melissa

    Thanks, Jake :) It’s good to be back.

Previous post:

Next post: